Title: Supreme Court’s 2023 Judgment on “Control Sexual Urges” Case: A Much-Needed Reality Check
When the Court Got It Wrong And Then Got It Right
Ever read something so absurd that you had to re-read it to believe it? That was my reaction when I stumbled upon the Calcutta High Court’s 2023 verdict suggesting adolescent girls should “control their sexual urges.” Really? In a rape case? It felt like a throwback to a time when moral policing passed for justice.
But here’s the thing—this wasn’t just offensive, it was dangerous.
Thankfully, the Supreme Court stepped in like the responsible adult in the room.
What the Supreme Court Actually Said
In August 2024, a bench led by Justices Abhay S. Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan slammed the earlier judgment as “sweeping, irrelevant, and preachy.” And they weren’t being dramatic—they were being just.
They overturned the acquittal of the accused, re-established the POCSO Act's authority, and most importantly, reminded every judge in the country that the courtroom isn’t a pulpit for outdated values.
Because let’s be honest—if we start blaming victims (especially minors) for being victims, where does it end?
Why This Judgment Matters (To You, Me, and Everyone)
This wasn’t just about correcting a verdict—it was about protecting every teenager’s right to be seen, heard, and treated with dignity.
It tells us:
- Judges must rule on law, not morality.
- Victims deserve protection, not preaching.
- Consent laws exist for a reason—and minors can’t give it. Period.
This isn’t about “urban values” versus “tradition.” It’s about basic constitutional rights.
FAQs
Q: What was controversial about the High Court’s 2023 ruling?
A: It advised adolescent girls to "control sexual urges" in a rape case, deflecting blame from the accused.
Q: What did the Supreme Court do?
A: It reversed the acquittal, reaffirmed the POCSO Act, and condemned the earlier court’s moralistic tone.
Final Thoughts: The Real Verdict Is Ours
Honestly, the Supreme Court did what it was supposed to do—uphold justice. But let’s not pretend the story ends there. This is also a moment for us to reflect. Are we still judging girls more harshly than boys? Are we okay with our institutions echoing patriarchal nonsense?
